Paleo Chicken Pot Pie

Chicken pot pie: quite possibly the epitome of comfort food and hands down one of my favorite meals ever. I’ve ordered chicken pot pies at hip & fancy DC restaurants on numerous occasions (I love them so much I’m willing to pay $25 for a single serving) and I truly just think they’re divine. Plus, the warm, buttery, flaky, slightly crispy, grain-free crust in this dish is really what takes this pot pie to the next level. Not sure if anyone can tell, but, I’ve on a cruuuucial pie crust kick since I adapted this Elana’s Pantry recipe.

I have to admit, frozen chicken pot pies were one of my favorite grocery store treats for almost all of my life. Marie Callender’s & Stouffer’s pot pies were my brother & I’s favorites as a child. You know, with the mildly-rubbery “chicken” cubes and delicious, yet, oh-so-fake “ingredients”.


Once I moved out, I usually would keep an organic vegetable pot pie for myself & a “natural” chicken pot pie for James in the freezer at all times. You know, for those halfway-lazy evenings, where I definitely didn’t want to cook, but, definitely didn’t want to succumb to the desperation of… *GASP* – SUSHI & CHINESE FOOD. Frozen pot pies kind of became my halfway house between home-cooked meals and delivery/take-out. The second to last stop on the bad-food guilt train. The last exit before the toll.


Either way… AT LAST! I’ll never have the guilty feeling of cooking a frozen meal for dinner with this recipe. Baking frozen pot pies tends to make me feel like I’m making a microwavable Lean Cuisine TV dinner and why buy them when you can easily make them from scratch! You’re going to spend at least 1 hour baking a frozen one, anyway, while it only takes 30 minutes to bake a fresh paleo one. These pot pies also are super easy to reheat the next day – simply cut the crust open a bit and pop under the broiler for a few minutes.

I was recently feeling lazy and was curious to find out what a pie with no bottom-crust is called. Turns out that’s a pot pie! This was surprising to me for some reason… Not sure why. I’ve made this pie double AND single-crusted, so, the choice is really up to you. I prefer a chicken pot pie with a single top crust. You may have also heard of the original Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie, but, that’s a whole ‘nutha story for a whole ‘nutha day…


Paleo Chicken Pot Pie
  • For the Single Crust:
  • 1-1/2 cups almond flour
  • 1/2 cup tapioca flour
  • 3 tbsp shortening or lard, chilled/frozen
  • 1 egg
  • 1 tsp water
  • 1/2 tsp dry sweetener of choice
  • 1/2 tsp sea salt
  • Simply double the ingredients & split dough in half for double-crust.
  • For the Chicken:
  • 1-1/2 lbs chicken breast tenderloins (I use about 5 tenderloins)
  • 1 tbsp [url href=”″ target=”_blank”]olive oil[/url]
  • 1/2 tsp sea salt
  • Freshly ground black pepper
  • For the Filling:
  • 1 can coconut milk (about 1-3/4 cups)
  • 1-2/3 cups chicken broth
  • 1 heaping cup chopped carrot
  • 1 cup diced potatoes
  • 1 cup diced onion (about 1 med/large onion)
  • 1/2 heaping cup finely diced celery
  • 2/3 cup frozen peas (opt. – [i]not[/i] paleo)
  • 1/2 cup sliced mushrooms (opt.)
  • 2 large cloves garlic, minced/grated
  • 2 tbsp tapioca flour
  • 1-1/2 tsp sea salt
  • 1 tsp freshly ground black pepper
  • 1 tsp [url href=”″ target=”_blank”]olive oil[/url]
  • 1 tbsp butter/ghee (you can use all oil, I just prefer the taste of butter)
  • Pinch of fresh or dried thyme (opt.)
Preheat oven to 400. Grease one 9-inch pie plate OR six 1-cup ramekins or mini pie dishes. (I bought mine from TJ Maxx for $15.)
For the Crust:
  1. Pulse all crust ingredients together in food processor until dough ball forms. Flatten into disk and wrap in saran wrap. Refrigerate while preparing filling.
For the Chicken:
  1. [img src=””]
  2. Toss chicken breast tenderloins in olive oil, salt, and pepper. Bake in preheated oven, covered, for 20 mins and uncovered for another 10 mins until internal temp reaches 165. Once cool enough to handle, dice cooked chicken into bite-sized chunks & set aside. Reduce oven heat to 350.
For the Filling:
  1. Bring a small to medium saucepan of water to a boil. Boil chopped carrots for 7-8 mins & remove with slotted spoon, then, boil diced potatoes for 6-7 mins & remove. Set parboiled veggies aside.
  2. Heat butter/ghee & oil in a large skillet or dutch oven over med heat and sauté onion & celery until translucent – about 5 mins. Add tapioca and mix until softened veggies are evenly coated in flour.
  3. Add coconut milk & chicken broth and bring to a boil, stirring frequently, for 6 mins until reduced & thickened.
  4. Add cooked & diced chicken, frozen peas, sliced mushrooms, parboiled carrots & potatoes, fresh garlic, salt & pepper. Mix & immediately remove from heat, then, pour into greased pie plate(s).
  5. Roll out chilled pie crust disk between two sheets of parchment/wax paper. Once you’ve cut your dough to fit your pie plate, use a sharp knife to create ventilation slits/a pretty design. (I prefer the classic flower-look.)
  6. Slide a thin cutting board or piece of cardboard underneath the cut pie crust and quickly (but carefully) flip the crust onto your pie. You can also [i]very[/i] quickly slide the crust off your board and onto your pie. Remember, any breaks or cracks can be pinched and patched back together.
  7. Place pot pies on a sheet tray and bake at 350 for first 15 mins, then, increase heat to 425 for remaining 20-25 mins until bubbly & golden brown.[br][img src=””]
  8. Let cool for 5-10 mins before serving.[br][img src=””]


  • Burning Man 2015 – Katie Cordoza

    01.05.2018 at 15:33 Reply

    […] Chicken Pot Pie – Original recipe from Paleo Comfort Foods. Here’s a similar online version: […]

  • Karen Johnson

    06.02.2017 at 20:35 Reply

    Do you think butter would be a good substitute for shortening or lard? Thanks!

  • Sarah Richards

    30.01.2017 at 19:17 Reply

    Not sure what happened, but the crust would not come together

  • Christina Pincock

    04.04.2016 at 21:00 Reply

    Sounds fantastic! I can’t wait to try it a paleo version of this. Can you use coconut flour instead of the blanched almond flour? I have this in my pantry already. Thanks for posting!

  • Victoria Strong

    03.04.2016 at 20:32 Reply

    Quick question: are those the mini pie dishes in your pictures? And how many did this recipe make?

  • "40 Cloves" Chicken {Paleo, Gluten-Free} - Merit + Fork

    18.03.2016 at 16:31 Reply

    […] while we’re talking about the best chicken ever… why not try the best Paleo Chicken Pot Pie […]

  • Jan Bishop

    20.01.2016 at 13:46 Reply

    This is so delicious! Thought I had to give up eating chicken pot pie but now do not have to. My kids liked this better than regular pot pie. Sauce is so good. Thank you!!!

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:31 Reply

      Thank you soooo much! and I totally agree, I think it’s better than regular pot pie! You are awesome. Thanks, again, and so glad you & your family enjoyed it!!

  • The Ultimate Paleo Chicken Recipes Round Up! - Oh Snap! Let's Eat!

    03.01.2016 at 17:32 Reply

    […] Paleo Chicken Pot Pie by Merit and Fork […]

  • Jessica R

    29.11.2015 at 22:16 Reply

    If I wanted to make these into individual pies to freeze and save for later, do I still cook them first and then let them cool and pop them in the freezer? Or assemble and leave uncooked to freeze?

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:28 Reply

      I assemble them, then, PAR-BAKE for 10-15 mins just until the crust is semi-set. Then cover with foil and freeze or refrigerate until ready to reheat. Just keep an eye on them when reheating in the oven – you want them bubbling and golden brown. Luckily the crust is very forgiving and does not burn quickly, so, there’s really no chance of “overcooking.”

  • Sara Sonoyama

    06.10.2015 at 21:50 Reply

    Absolutely delish!

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:24 Reply

      THANK YOU SO MUCH you sweet potpie angel. <3

  • Kate Hurley

    20.09.2015 at 20:26 Reply

    Could I prep this 100% and cook it tomorrow for dinner?

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:23 Reply

      Absolutely. I do it all the time. I recommend par-baking it for 10-15 mins just to set the crust a bit and then freeze or refrigerate, covered, until ready to reheat.

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:29 Reply

      I assemble them, then, par-bake for 10-15 mins just until the crust is semi-set. Then cover with foil and freeze or refrigerate until ready to reheat. Just keep an eye on them when reheating in the oven – you want them bubbling and golden brown. Luckily the crust is very forgiving and does not burn quickly, so, there’s really no chance of “overcooking.”

  • Amy C

    16.09.2015 at 21:33 Reply

    I made this tonight and we loved it! Even my picky boys gobbled it up!

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:22 Reply

      Thank you SO SO SO much!!! it’s definitely a favorite around here with my picky boyfriend.

  • Sally Huffman

    22.08.2015 at 16:36 Reply

    Made this last night for dinner and it was DELICIOUS!!! Crust was flaky and so, so good! This is comfort food at it’s best!

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:21 Reply

      You are officially my favorite.

  • Melissa jones

    20.08.2015 at 12:23 Reply

    Just made this for my family of picky eaters (7,10,34 year olds) and they devoured it! Was amazed that the kids loved it considering they are used to the traditional pot pie with everything bad! Making this again for sure!

    • Melissa jones

      20.08.2015 at 12:24 Reply

      Got click happy, this should have 5 stars!

    • Nicole

      21.08.2015 at 02:34 Reply

      Thank you! So so sooo nice to hear that! :) Kendra at makes this for her 3 small children as well on a regular basis, so, it must be super kid-friendly. Thank goodness I’ve got the palette of a 5 year old ’cause little tastebuds are definitely the hardest to please. Thanks so much again, Melissa! Hope you guys try (& love) some more recipes!


  • Top 35 Paleo Recipes of 2014 -

    28.12.2014 at 22:58 Reply

    […] Paleo Chicken Pot Pie from Merit and Fork […]

Post a Reply to Nicole Cancel Reply