Paleo Black ‘N Blueberry Pie

This post is officially my last summer-berry hoorah. Anyone who knows me knows that I’m a sucker for bargains/sales and anything food related. This means I regularly buy a plethora of unnecessary kitchen items, whether it’s new & whacky ingredients, handy & unique (but still mostly useless) kitchen utensils, or a crapton of fresh berries. Pretty much anytime there was a berry sale over the last 3 months, I bought & froze 2-4 boxes. (FYI, the summer has berry sales every day, all season -er, wait, make that ALL YEAR- long… sigh. What’s wrong with meeee.)

As you can imagine, my freezer is packed with fresh, ripe berries & cherries galore and our kitchen (and every cabinet in the living room… oops. need new house plz.) is packed with kitchen tools, appliances, dishes & food photography props. Ask me about the most bizarre ingredient or tool you can think of and I guarantee I’ll have it. Cherry pitter even though I haven’t pitted cherries in 5 years? NEED IT. Strawberry huller even though I haven’t hulled strawberries in 10 years? NEED IT. Avocado slicer even though I hate avocados? DEFINITELY NEED IT. Eco-friendly overpriced-bamboo potato scrubber? YUP. I’m one of those idiots keeping the Hutzler 571 Banana Slicer in production.

My secret is… I go to TJ Maxx and become a Maxxinista. They always have new, popular items and they’re always selling discounted Le Creuset pieces. I mean, yeah a 9×13 Le Creuset baking dish is still $30, but, that’s just fine with me because DISCOUNT. I always leave TJ Maxx spending about $200, feeling fairly guilt-ridden and sad that again, I could not exercise self-control. I JUST NEEDED ALL THE KITCHEN THINGS. WHYYY, GOD, WHY. This definitely does not stop at TJ Maxx, either… send me to any grocery store, farmers market, or roadside stand and I go apeshit. I simply love fresh produce and trying new things. Even if that new thing is a $20 salami from some hip & trendy organic Salumeria or $100 in exotic spices & halal meats from my local Indo-Pak grocer. Hey, at least I’m not spending my money on clothes and shoes, right? IT’S FOR THE GOOD OF THE BLOG, PEOPLE.

If you’re picturing my tiny freezer packed full of frozen berry clamshells, your vision is correct! (I would store them in the chest freezer… if that wasn’t packed, too.) As you can expect, I really need to use those fresh summer berries. I figured now is better than ever to post this recipe since you can still get perfectly ripe berries almost anywhere and, soon, we’ll be transitioning into more Autumnal recipes. (I’ve always wanted to use that word.) Can I get a “WOOP WOOP!” from all my pumpkin-spice-loving yoga-pant-wearers!?


The crust is an adapted version of an Elana’s Pantry pie crust and is, in my opinion, awesome! It tastes just like the real thing and until I develop my own wow-worthy pie crust recipe, I will continue to use and love this slightly adapted version. I replaced some of the almond flour with tapioca starch to prevent over-browning and used a bit more lard/shortening in place of the coconut oil. You do need to be more careful with it than a typical glutenous pie crust, but, if you’ve worked with almond flour-based pie crust before, you know what you’re working with, just gotta pinch any cracks back together. The toughest part is flipping the top crust onto the pie, but, I’ve never messed it up to the point where it’s unsalvageable. If you’re careful, you’ll have perfect paleo pie crust in no time. You can use this crust for sweet OR savory dishes, too! (chicken pot pie. mmmmmm)

This pie is so, so, so easy to make and you can fill it with virtually any type of fruit you want. I personally think it tastes, like most dishes, even better the day after making it. Once the filling has time to cool, it gets thick & gooey and you don’t have to worry about the hot, melted contents of your pie slice oozing all over your plate. Let the tapioca do it’s job overnight and ENJOY!





  • 100+ Paleo Berry Recipes

    14.03.2018 at 12:03 Reply

    […] Paleo Black’ N Blueberry Pie from Merit and Fork  […]

  • Weeks 5 and 6: Oven Ribs, Blackberry / Blueberry Paleo Pie, Mexican Breakfast Casserole | A Year in Cooking Adventures

    29.03.2016 at 21:35 Reply

    […] and blueberries that were tossed with lemon juice and zest, honey, and agave nectar. The recipe is here.  So making a pie was not as terrible as I thought it was going to be (and with my trusty baking […]

  • Leslie Nikula

    29.01.2016 at 17:40 Reply

    I made this last weekend, first pie I’ve ever made. I made it for a dinner party and everyone went nuts. Thanks for the fantastic recipe!

    • Nicole

      18.03.2016 at 17:20 Reply

      How am I just seeing this?!?! You are a goddess!!! Thank you!!!! My heart has melted. <3

  • Cindy

    29.09.2014 at 09:02 Reply

    Could I use frozen blueberries for this recipe or will it get too mushy? Thank you!

    • Nicole

      01.10.2014 at 09:06 Reply

      You absolutely could! I would just suggest that you slightly thaw & drain the berries beforehand.

    • Nicole

      01.10.2014 at 09:08 Reply

      and as suggested, I’d wait overnight for the tapioca-berry filling to cool and thicken before slicing & serving. Using frozen, you may be dealing with a slightly more liquidy center when fresh-out-the-oven. Either way, it’s always better after it’s had a chance to cool for a few hours.

  • Susan

    26.09.2014 at 10:38 Reply

    That looks delicious! Wish I were there to test it for you :)

    • Nicole

      01.10.2014 at 09:05 Reply

      Thanks Aunt Sue! Wish you were here, too! Thanksgiving & Christmas is going to be frighteningly absent without you guys.

Post a Comment